Bubble Bible
Sign in
All questions

Why does God allow suffering and evil?

EthicsMulti-view · no verdict

Short answer

This is the hardest question in theology ("theodicy"), and Christians answer it in several different ways, the major approaches below are presented factually, none endorsed. Scripture is striking for what it does not do: in its central meditation on the problem, the book of Job, God answers the sufferer with his own presence and sovereignty but gives no tidy explanation (Job.38-42). What the Bible does affirm: suffering entered through the fall (Genesis 3); it is not always punishment for personal sin (John 9:1-3; Luke 13:1-5); present suffering is real but is being worked toward good and final glory (Romans 8:18-28; 2 Corinthians 4:17); and God himself entered suffering in Christ rather than staying distant from it. The differing "theodicies", free-will, soul-making, greater-good/sovereignty, mystery (Joban), and open-theism, are each held by serious Christians and are set out below.

Question

Why does God allow suffering and evil?

Analysis

The biblical data (largely agreed)

ThemeTextsWhat it establishes
Suffering is real and is not minimized~1/3 of the Psalms are laments (Psalms 13, Psalms 22, Psalms 88); Jesus wept (John 11:35)Scripture never tells sufferers to pretend; it gives them honest words.
Origin in the fallGenesis 3 (curse, pain, death enters); Romans 5:12Suffering and death are intruders into a good creation, not part of its original design.
Not always personal-sin punishmentJohn 9:1-3 ("neither hath this man sinned, nor his parents"); Luke 13:1-5 (tower of Siloam, "think ye that they were sinners above all…? I tell you, Nay")Jesus explicitly rejects the assumption that suffering measures guilt.
No tidy answer given, JobJob.38-42, God answers from the whirlwind with creation's vastness, not an explanation; Job's friends' "you must have sinned" theology is rebukedThe Bible's longest treatment refuses a neat formula. Job receives presence and sovereignty, not a reason.
Worked toward good and gloryRomans 8:18 ("the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory"); Romans 8:28 ("all things work together for good"); 2 Corinthians 4:17 ("light affliction… worketh… eternal weight of glory")Suffering is bounded, purposeful, and not the last word, though Romans 8:28's "good" is defined as conformity to Christ (Romans 8:29), not "things turning out pleasantly."
God suffers with us in ChristGethsemane (Matthew 26:38-39); the cross; "touched with the feeling of our infirmities" (Hebrews 4:15)The Christian claim is not that God explains suffering from a distance but that he entered it.
Final resolutionRevelation 21:4, "God shall wipe away all tears… no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying"Suffering is temporary; the new creation ends it.

A note Scripture is careful about: Romans 8:28 is a promise of ultimate good (Christlikeness, Romans 8:29), not a guarantee that every painful thing will resolve comfortably in this life. Misusing it as a quick fix (…) is widely cautioned against pastorally.

The major theodicies (how Christians explain the "why")

These are not all mutually exclusive, many thoughtful Christians blend several. Presented factually; this reference endorses none.

ViewPositionHeld by (tradition)
Free-will theodicyGod made genuinely free creatures; much suffering results from the misuse of that freedom (sin, cruelty, injustice). A world with real love requires real freedom, which can be abused.Augustine (with qualifications); Alvin Plantinga; classical Arminian, Roman Catholic, and Eastern Orthodox emphasis. Strong on moral evil; weaker on natural disaster and animal/infant suffering.
Soul-making theodicySuffering is the necessary environment for spiritual and moral growth; character, endurance, and hope are forged through hardship (Romans 5:3-5; James 1:2-4).The Irenaean tradition; John Hick (in a modern form); echoed in much devotional theology. Critiqued where suffering seems to crush rather than form.
Greater-good / sovereignty theodicyGod permits suffering to bring about greater goods we often cannot see; his wisdom and purposes exceed our knowledge (Genesis 50:20, "ye thought evil… but God meant it unto good"; Romans 11:33).Much classical theism; emphasized in Reformed/Calvinist traditions stressing God's sovereign ordering of all things. Critiqued as sometimes sounding dismissive to the sufferer.
Mystery / Joban theodicyWe cannot fully explain suffering; God's character is trustworthy, so we entrust ourselves to him without resolving the "why." Follows Job's own pattern.Much pastoral counseling and biblical wisdom literature; embraced across traditions. Honest about the limits of explanation; critiqued for leaving the intellectual problem open.
Open theismGod does not exhaustively foreknow or determine future free choices; he responds in real time to a genuinely open world, and so is not the author of specific evils.A minority of evangelical theologians (e.g. Boyd, Sanders, Pinnock). Rejected by the mainstream, which holds to exhaustive divine foreknowledge.

Most traditions also affirm a Christ-centered and eschatological dimension alongside whichever theodicy they hold: that God shares our suffering in Christ (Moltmann, Bonhoeffer) and that the new creation will finally resolve what is now unresolved (Revelation 21:4), points nearly all Christians hold in common.

Two sub-problems often run together

Theodicy discussions sharpen when two distinct questions are separated:

Sub-problemWhat it asksWhich theodicies speak to it best
Moral evilWhy does God allow human cruelty, sin, and injustice?Free-will theodicy is strongest here, genuine freedom can be abused.
Natural evilWhy disease, disaster, "acts of God" that no human chose?Free-will is weaker here; greater-good/sovereignty, soul-making, fall-of-creation (Romans 8:20-22, creation "subjected to vanity"), and mystery do more work.

Scripture also holds out a further frame across both: present groaning is the labor-pain of a creation awaiting redemption (Romans 8:22), suffering is not the permanent shape of the world.

A distinction most traditions make: God causing vs. permitting

A recurring sub-debate is whether God ordains/causes suffering or permits it within his sovereign frame:

ViewPosition
Strong sovereigntyGod ordains suffering for purposes we may not see; secondary agents bear the moral responsibility (Reformed emphasis; Genesis 50:20; Job.1-2).
Permissive willGod permits but does not directly author evil, using it for greater purposes (much Catholic and Arminian).
OpenGod responds to a genuinely open world he does not exhaustively determine (open theism, minority).

All three insist God is not the author of sin and is good, they differ on the mechanics of how his sovereignty and creaturely evil relate.

What Job actually teaches (the model case)

  1. Job is righteous, yet he suffers (the prologue, Job.1-2, makes this explicit).
  2. His friends' retribution theology (…) is shown to be inadequate and is rebuked (Job 42:7).
  3. Job demands an explanation from God.
  4. God answers from the whirlwind (Job.38-41), displaying his sovereignty and the vastness of creation, not explaining the reason.
  5. Job rests (Job 42:1-6), not because he learned the cause, but because he met God.

The takeaway endorsed across traditions: God's reply to suffering is ultimately his presence and trustworthiness, not a formula.

The pastoral counsel that crosses traditions

PracticeTexts
Honest lament is allowed and godlythe lament Psalms; Lamentations 3
Don't impose a cause on a suffererJob's friends as the warning; John 9:1-3
Be present before being explanatoryJob's friends were best when silent (Job.2:13)
Hold hope without denying painRomans 8:18-25; 2 Corinthians 1:3-7
Trust God's character amid mysterythe Joban pattern; Proverbs 3:5

Sources, trace every one

Every cited verse, in full. Tap any reference to open it in the reader.

  • John 9:1bsb

    Now as Jesus was passing by, He saw a man blind from birth,

  • Luke 13:1bsb

    At that time some of those present told Jesus about the Galileans whose blood Pilate had mixed with their sacrifices.

  • Romans 8:18bsb

    I consider that our present sufferings are not comparable to the glory that will be revealed in us.

  • 2 Corinthians 4:17bsb

    For our light and momentary affliction is producing for us an eternal weight of glory that is far beyond comparison.

  • John 11:35bsb

    Jesus wept.

  • Romans 5:12bsb

    Therefore, just as sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin, so also death was passed on to all men, because all sinned.

  • Romans 8:28bsb

    And we know that God works all things together for the good of those who love Him, who are called according to His purpose.

  • Romans 8:29bsb

    For those God foreknew, He also predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son, so that He would be the firstborn among many brothers.

  • Matthew 26:38bsb

    Then He said to them, “My soul is consumed with sorrow to the point of death. Stay here and keep watch with Me.”

  • Hebrews 4:15bsb

    For we do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but we have one who was tempted in every way that we are, yet was without sin.

  • Revelation 21:4bsb

    ‘He will wipe away every tear from their eyes,’ and there will be no more death or mourning or crying or pain, for the former things have passed away.”

  • Romans 5:3bsb

    Not only that, but we also rejoice in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perseverance;

  • James 1:2bsb

    Consider it pure joy, my brothers, when you encounter trials of many kinds,

  • Genesis 50:20bsb

    As for you, what you intended against me for evil, God intended for good, in order to accomplish a day like this— to preserve the lives of many people.

  • Romans 11:33bsb

    O, the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are His judgments, and untraceable His ways!

  • Romans 8:20bsb

    For the creation was subjected to futility, not by its own will, but because of the One who subjected it, in hope

On contested questions we show every major view, attributed and cited, and pick no winner. Answers are synthesized from primary sources, truth you can trace, not opinion.

Why does God allow suffering and evil? · Bubble Bible